He is not a comfort nurser either - he sucks his thumb. We also don't use pacifiers, he really never would take one and I was afraid it would interfere with nursing at first, I also never wanted to try and break a pacifier habit when he was older - so I strongly discouraged it. We have been doing the sippy cup thing - my pumping output is very poor for some reason, but I am going to try and pump/powerpump this weekend and see if that helps. Will try the bathtub tonight - keeping my fingers crossed! thank you sixyearplan!